Thursday, January 24, 2013

Week 3: Cognitive Theory 2

How do the ideas from class make their way into your everyday life? How do ideas from your everyday life make it into class? Describe the kinds of transfer that is happening as these things make it from class to your everyday life and visa versa. Can  you really learn without these two things (your life and class) overlapping?

13 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The ideas from class present themselves often in my everyday life. Related to the topic of learning, I am constantly assimilating and accommodating new information. For example, when I learn things in class, such as how children behave in certain situations, I may assimilate the new information by relating it to my previous knowledge and experiences with children. However, when I witness this behavior in person, such as in my service learning site, I may realize that my initial understanding of the subject matter was incorrect and therefore adjust my perspective to allow for the new knowledge.
    The ideas from my everyday life make it into class every day because whenever I learn new information, I am comparing it to previously acquired knowledge. Every year, information builds on that learned previously, like when learning new math concepts. In the ECFS major I am constantly and more often bringing my insights from teaching dance classes, volunteering in a Head Start classroom, and interacting with children, which is guiding my learning. I then take the information I learn in class, such as how to successfully reach a group of children when they are all from different cultural backgrounds, and apply it back to my experiences outside the classroom. It is a constant cycle of continuous learning and transfer.
    Positive transfer is occurring when I apply information from class to my everyday life and vice versa. The transfer can be near or far depending on the circumstance. For example, when I learn about the mind and behavior of a child and let it influence my activities with children in a classroom, positive far transfer is occurring because the situation has changed yet the information is similar and related. In a case, however, in which I learn something like how to rate a classroom and then use the same rating system in real life, positive near transfer has occurred.
    I think that, though it helps, a formal classroom does not necessarily need to be present to really learn, but I think that real life experiences are critical to real learning. Having outside experiences and interacting with others contributes greatly to a person’s learning. I believe that if someone were to only spend time in a classroom and never go out into the real world, they would not truly learn. This is because while they learn the concepts, they may never truly understand them because they would never have experienced or witnessed them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very good relations are explained in your blog. The fact that you are getting to learn about kids and then observe your learnings is a very clear example of a transfer which would be very helpful. You mention that often times experiences make learnings more clear or redefine what you have learned and as I read this I realized it was very true. When learning it is hard for a teacher to reach all of their students clearly so experiences are very important to clear ideas up and engrain knowledge into your mind. I agree also with your last paragraph about learning through experiences because personally that is what most strongly affects my knowledge.

      Delete
    2. I like what you said about how you are always comparing new information presented to you in class with your previous knowledge and that you are therefore constantly assimilating it into existing schemes or accommodating your schemes to fit the new information.

      I agree that learning through experience is one of the best ways to ensure real learning. Relating material learned in class to real life things is a good way to do this. It must be hard for teachers to think of ways to do this because every student has had different and unique experiences.

      Delete
  3. For ideas from class to transfer to my everyday life they need to have not only resonated with me in some way whether it be interesting to me or just a good understanding but they also need to come up in some way in my everyday life. I often times will learn things in class and never think about them before because I don’t have the need to. However, when life presents me with a situation that involves something that I have learned I tend to remember learning it and apply it to my current situation. As far as the transfer between life and class, I feel skills learned in life are constantly being transferred such as cooperation, manners and experiences that can be applied to better help one understand their learning’s. I believe often times the type of transfer between school and life experiences is far transfer (positive or negative depending on how one uses it) because you are in two separate settings and the purpose for the application of the information you learned often times different.

    While I would like to say you can’t learn without these two overlapping, for the purpose of my time being spent in school, I believe you can learn without schooling. Over the summer, I work for my mom’s very successful company and the president of many years didn’t have any schooling further than high school. I have heard of many other cases in which a person becomes successful and learns through experiences rather than schooling. While you can argue the fact that he did have some schooling, I believe after one learns the basics such as reading, writing and math they have the skills to succeed if the motivation is there without schooling.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I thought you brought up an interesting idea when you talked about how schooling isn't a necessity for learning. I do agree with this to some extent but it is interesting to think about where the line is between schooling being beneficial and unnecessary.

      Delete
    2. I agree that schooling is not always necessary for real learning to occur, and like how you related this concept to the president of your mom's company not having formal schooling past high school. I believe that after a certain point, life experiences can be much more helpful than plain facts learned in a classroom setting.

      Delete
    3. I, too, believe that real learning doesn't necessarily occur within school. You gave us a great example using your personal experience. Also, I agree with your idea of how we can learn manners and cooperations in school because even though teaching manners and cooperations aren't the main purpose of schooling, they relate much better to our life rather than calculus or chemistry.

      Delete
  4. When I can find a way to connect things I learn in class to my own prior knowledge it has a lot better chance of sticking with me. If I find these things interesting or useful then they will make their way into my everyday life. I think this happens more than I acknowledge that it does. I am pretty sure that I use things I learned in school every day but just don't realize it.

    I think real learning happens when you can relate concepts learned in class to a real life setting (aka using far transfer). Just being able to use what you learn in class to pass a test (near transfer)is not real learning. Getting students to be able to use their knowledge beyond the classroom setting is after all, the point of education.

    I think that you can also learn things outside of the classroom that are useful in the school setting. This back and forth application of knowledge learnt is what makes learning real and long lasting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also have a much easier time remembering information when I am able to relate it to previous knowledge, and agree that sometimes these connections are not always made consciously. I like how you distinguished near and far transfer when relating it to real learning. I agree that when you memorize information solely for a test, you are not truly learning. You have to be able to use the information outside the classroom to know that you have really learned.

      Delete
    2. I agree with you in saying that far transfer signifies real learning much better than near transfer does. When a person figures out how to apply what they learn in other various situations, then it shows that the person has a strong understanding of the concept/idea. Far transfer is an important indicator that real learning has happened.

      Delete
  5. When I understand and learn new ideas and concepts from class, they affect how I think/behave in life. I apply the concepts and ideas learned in class to real life situations, but this requires full understanding. This is a positive far transfer. When I attempt to apply what I learn in class to my everyday life but does it incorrectly, then it results in negative far transfers.

    Ideas from my everyday life make it into class by helping me to understand the ideas that are present in class. My background knowledge from everyday life helps me to learn new concepts and ideas easily. I tend to learn better when ideas presented in class can be related to what I already know. This would also be positive far transfer.

    I do not believe that I can really learn without these two things overlapping. If i cannot apply the ideas I learn in class to everyday life, then it means that I do not have the full understanding of the new ideas. Also, without my background knowledge learned from everyday life, it would be extremely difficult for me to learn new ideas in class.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Being able to relate ideas learned outside of class is a very important process of my learning as well. I think a part of it is having been exposed to the concepts makes it easier to piece together and fit into everyday life. After todays discussion I too believe that classroom and out of class learning must overlap because so much of it is related to one another.

    ReplyDelete