Friday, January 11, 2013

Week 1: Behaviorism

Choose 2-3 Behavior Week concepts you'd like to discuss about, and please explain why. It could be that the concept really resonated with you, you found it to be interesting, or you found it to be confusing. Make sure to provide examples of these concepts that you've encountered in your daily life! How do you find the Behaviorist theory and its practices so far? (I.e. Do you think real learning is all change in observable behavior like Skinner?)

13 comments:

  1. I thought the ideas of mastery vs. understanding that we read about and discussed this week really resonated with me, in particular, the discussion of these two things in terms of teaching and learning math. I had an experience similar to Benny’s, in the article written by Erlwanger, in my high school AP calculus class. I had perhaps, a bit more understanding of calculus than Benny did of fractions, but there was definitely a gap between me solving the math problems and me understanding what they meant. For instance, I could take derivatives and integrals without much issue, but often times I could not solve word problems. Any time the formula with which to solve the problem was not directly spelled out for me, I struggled to understand how to get the answer, or what the answer even was supposed to mean. My teacher worked hard to relate the formulas we learned to graphs so we could understand mathematically where they came from, but the connections between those graphs and real life situations was often hard to see. I do not think I ever really understood entirely what taking a derivative of an equation meant even though I “mastered” the process of taking derivatives. This just goes to show us that real learning cannot be equivalent to getting correct answers because I was able to get an A in that class while barely passing the AP test which does include many word problems in order to test our understanding of concepts. This makes me question Skinner’s ideas of behaviorism. At least for some things, reinforcing certain behaviors does not result in real learning. There is a lot of room for a lack of understanding if you are simply being taught by whether or not you receive good grades.

    Jillian Johnson

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can relate to your story about how solving word problems are a lot harder than using formulas. I think being able to apply what you are taught to situations is the biggest difference between mastery and understanding. Also, you mentioned that reinforcing certain behaviors does not result in real learning, but I believe that reinforcement can be a great aid for real learning if it is supplemented with other methods of teaching.

      Delete
    2. I can also relate to your experience with mastery versus understanding. I took ap calculus my senior year of high school, and though I had understood math well before that year, I was completely stumped when it came to things like derivatives and integrals. I was able to come to the correct answer on homework assignments and tests, but still have no idea what it actually means to take a derivative or find an integral. Though I mastered the tests and homework, I definitely did not understand the concept of calculus. I believe it is important to have had these experiences to personally further understand behaviorism and specifically the idea of mastery versus understanding.

      Delete
    3. I really like your relation to AP calculus becuase I experienced the same thing. I experienced an extreme case of mastery, our teacher told us that our test would consist of questions within a book of problems that we were practicing with. Since I knew this and wasnt understanding the reasoning behind how and when to apply my knowledge (or lack of knowledge) I would spend hours practicing the problems in the book, essentially mastering them hoping they would show up on the test. My lack of understanding continues in math today.

      Delete
  2. A topic I found particularly interesting this week was the difference between mastery and understanding. I feel I was best able to relate my schooling to these terms. Growing up I was always such a pleaser and getting good grades was one of my top priorities which caused me to often times master subjects by just memorizing the facts that I knew I would need to know rather than really attempting to understand how the information I was learning came to be. I think understanding is a really important factor that teachers need to stress because it hinders students from moving forward. Going from one concept to the next without knowing the reasoning behind the answers causes things to get confusing as I saw as I progressed in my math classes.

    I also found reinforcement very interesting. I knew this concept was used in teaching but never looked into how prevalent it actually is. Reinforcement shows up in practically everything I have done; learning to talk, learning to count, learning my abc’s. It is such a huge part of our lives and it is often over looked. We so often talk about reinforcement in terms of clinical studies I never really thought to apply it to myself and my everyday functions.

    From what we have discussed about Behaviorism I don’t believe real learning is demonstrated purely through physical changes. One can falsely be lead to believing they are learning through physical changes in behavior which leads me to believe that there are mental aspects of learning. I don’t exactly know how to measure this yet but there are many options such as explaining why one is doing something, applying the knowledge to other aspects of life and explaining how to get to the answer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really liked what you said about one being falsely led to believe that they are learning because of physical changes in behavior. Rote learning and memorization do not always imply understanding even if it feels like we know what we are doing.

      Delete
    2. I also see that our public education pushes students towards mastery rather than understanding. Often times students are required to memorize class material to do well on tests and quizzes, but not enough students are brought to true understanding of what they are being taught. I hope this issues gets addressed soon in the future.

      Delete
    3. I also experienced mastery throughout my schooling. In elementary and high school, I was good at memorizing information specifically for a test. However, the minute I left the classroom after the test I forgot most of the information I was required to know. I now realize this is because I mastered the subject matter; I didn't understand it. I like the connection you made between mastery and understanding in schooling.

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The two concepts that intrigued me the most are Mastery and Understanding. I am more than familiar with these words, but I did not think of the difference between the two in the way we discussed in class. An example of mastery I have encountered is when I took Microeconomics. In the class I learned various equations and rules I could use to solve a problem. I plugged in some numbers into the equations and got my answers. I mastered the equations. I ended up getting a good grade in the class, but I feel like I didn't really learn from the class because I don't remember anything. An example of understanding I have encountered is from my service-learning class. In the class we learn about educational concepts. Then, I have an opportunity to go into a preschool classroom and apply what I learned from the classroom into a real life situation. It helps me to truly understand the concepts, and it alters how I behave and treat the students.

    I partially agree with Skinner in saying that real learning is all change in observable behavior. Real learning may change observable behavior, but it can also result in change in unobservable behavior. For example, real learning can change the way one thinks or perceives the world. In this case, these changes are not physically observable, but it is a change in behavior. Also, change in observable behavior can be caused by reinforcement rather than real learning. When someone is reinforced over and over to behave certain way, then the reinforcement will change his/her observable behavior even though s/he did not experience real learning.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also had a hard time in Microeconomics because I was simply memorizing equations instead of thinking about what they meant. Additionally, I agree with your comment on how real learning affects the way you perceive the world. If I had really learned anything from that econ class I could use that in my own life when I think about economic or other world issues.

      Delete
    2. I like what you said about how observable behavior can be caused by reinforcement rather than learning. As we have seen in many examples within our readings children (at least up to a certain age) want to please people and to do that in a classroom you often have to get right answers. As we have learned getting right answers does not conclude that one has understood a concept but rather mastered it. Children often dont look at learning as a opportunity to better themselves but rather please others.

      Delete
  5. One behavior concept I found particularly interesting was the idea of mastery versus understanding. Though both words were very familiar to me before I took this class, I never considered the difference between them. Now that I’ve had time to reflect on the topics, I realize that I’ve experienced both in my life. For example, I experienced mastery in my high school AP biology class, when I was able to memorize information and get the correct answers on tests. However, I never truly made sense of how the different things we studied were related, such as how different parts of the body worked together. On the contrary, I have experienced understanding in the classes I’ve taken within the ECFS major. I understand why it is important to study the concepts we’re learning about, and can see the information I learn in action whenever I interact with children outside the classroom. Another thing I found interesting was the idea of reinforcement. I’ve used reinforcement in my own experiences, such as while babysitting. For instance, I’ve allowed the kids to have dessert after dinner if they behave well during the day.

    I find the behaviorist theory so far to be very relatable. A lot of the concepts, particularly involving punishments or reinforcements and the idea of mastery versus understanding, apply to various parts of my daily life. However, I do not fully agree with Skinner that the real learning is all change in observable behavior. I think a person can have a change in understanding or thought that sometimes influences behavior but do not have to be concrete and observable. This can count as real learning in my opinion as well, in addition to changes in observable behavior.

    ReplyDelete