Week 2: Cognitive Theory 1
What goes on in your mind when others are talking to you? Are you picturing things like the Fish from the story in Tuesday's class, or are you doing something else? Do you think what's happening in your mind is the same as what the speaker intended, or is it a different version (or maybe completely different)? What happens when you try to determine if you're really thinking about the same thing?
When people are explaining things to me that I have never experienced before, my first response is to make an assumption about it in my head based off things I have already experienced, like the fish does in the story. The image I have in my head is not going to be the same image that the other person has in their head. Asking questions to get the other person to describe what they mean in more detail will help get both people on the same page. Often times, our mental images are still going to be different even after questioning. According to Mayer, “learning is a change in knowledge attributable to experience.” By this definition, one cannot really learn about something until they themselves have experienced it, despite others trying to tell them about it. Until I experience the thing the other person was describing for myself I will have an altered idea or image of whatever is being discussed in my head. I don’t think anyone can really expect you to be able to know exactly what something is like until you experience it for yourself.
ReplyDeleteI like how you connected what goes on in your mind when listening to another person to Mayer's definition of learning. I also try to envision the scenario when listening to what another person is saying. I agree that when doing this, our idea is probably always going to be different than the speaker's because we have had different experiences which help dictate our current thoughts and beliefs. Mayer's belief that learning is based on experience relate really well to this idea.
DeleteI am a little more skeptical about making any assumption when I hear about something for the first time. It is really hard for me to do that. However, I completely agree with you in saying that asking clarifying questions help to establish stronger connection between the speaker's intention and what the listener has in mind. Although, this will not make us to imagine the same experience the speaker had. I, too, believe that unless the listener has the same exact experience, it is impossible to accurately imagine what the speaker is saying.
DeleteWhen others are talking to me many different things can be going on, depending on the way the speaker is describing the event. If they are very descriptive I will probably be trying to form a mental image of the situation and all of its details. My images are often constructed through my previous experiences. However, if the speaker is struggling to get their point across I will probably just be trying to make sense of things. I think most often what is going on in my head is different to what the speaker is describing because our background knowledge is different so we probably can’t construct the exact same image unless we have both experienced it. If the emphasis is on the speaker and I thinking of the same thing I believe questions must be involved for example, “The one by the tall tree?” or if you have had the same experiences you can relate things back to shared experiences for example, “The building looked like our school”. This process of constructivism allows the listener to work along with the speaker as a student and teacher would to form the ‘correct’ image.
ReplyDeleteI liked the examples you gave for how we can try to connect our mental images to those of the speaker. You're absolutely right in saying that the specificity of the speaker in their descriptions makes a difference in how well we are able to correctly picture what is going on. Relating new ideas to shared experiences from the past is a great way to get a message across.
DeleteI agree with you in saying that the way the speaker describes something is important for the listeners. Perhaps if the speaker is more descriptive, it is easier for the listener to try to imagine what the experience would be like without actually experiencing it. However, I also believe that how much interest the listener has in the subject is just as important. For example, if the listener is not at all interested in what the speaker is saying, then no matter how descriptive the speaker is, the listener will have hard time forming a mental image.
DeleteI am a very visual person. Therefore, whether I am conscious of it or not, I tend to envision the circumstances when other people are talking to me or telling me a story. I do not think there is any way to really make sure I understand exactly what the speaker is saying, because we both have different background knowledge that we are applying the information to. Certain things help clear the image, such as if I have been in the location of a story before or done a certain activity, because I am better able to visualize it. However, depending on how descriptive the other person is, I can either have a similar idea to what they are saying or a very different one. When I try to determine if we are really thinking about the same thing, such as by asking questions, my understanding may be a little closer to what was intended, but there is really no way of making sure it is exactly accurate. How I understand the information is influenced by how I am able to categorize the new information with previously learned concepts. Because the speaker and I have different background knowledge and therefore different schemata, it might cause me to construct the information in a way that is different than the intention of the speaker.
ReplyDeleteI liked how you talked about connecting what the speaker is saying to your own background knowledge. When we are trying to make sense of new things we are categorizing them into our schema, thereby updating our index of knowledge.
DeleteHaving similar background knowledge and being familiar with a certain location does allow for a better interpretation of a story. For example when someone is telling me a story say from my high school about people I know I am very intrigued and am picturing the whole scenario in my mind. However, when I listen to someone from another school tell a story about something that happened in their high school with their friends I am not as intrigued. This to me shows that being able to construct knowledge in a way one knows is correct is very important in relating to a listener.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhen others are talking to me, I try to understand the content through what I already know. If it makes absolutely no sense to me, then I tend to listen passively (which isn't good). I tend to understand better if I have a background knowledge related to what the speaker is saying. I don't necessarily picture things since I am not a visual person, but I use my background knowledge to process what I am hearing. The most power I have as a listener is to try to process what I hear so that it makes the most sense to me. I know that it is not the same as what the speaker intended because I don't think it is ever possible unless if I have the same exact experience. The speaker and I have different schema, experiences, and background knowledge. How closely I understand the speaker's intention depends on how descriptive the speaker is. Therefore, there is no way for me know if what is in my mind is the same as what the speaker intended. However, I can try my best to be as accurate as possible through asking clarifying questions to the speaker.
ReplyDeleteThough I differ in that I try to visualize the speaker's point, I also believe that my understanding has a lot to do with my previous experiences and background knowledge. I like what you said about listening passively when the information doesn't relate to you, because I realized that I, too, tend to become more passive when I don't feel a personal connection to the information, or if I can't find the importance of the information. I work much harder to learn or understand information that I find interesting or relevant.
DeleteI agree with you in the fact that I am not a visual person. I need to have seen what the speaker is talking about to visualize it myself. I too just try to make sense of the story and what occured rather than replaying it in my head as the speaker would be doing. I like how you kind of state there is so much unknown in the interaction between the speaker and the listener becuase it is something that I never think about but rather just assume I am understanding the speaker.
Delete